The Big Jim's Menu

Way more than pizza.

Yes, the NY-style and the deep dish are the headliners. But the calzones, subs, burgers, gyros, wings, pasta, and salads are why the whole table stays happy.

Order Delivery Order Pickup

Big Jim's loaded pizza on a checkered tray

Bring an appetite.

Pizza & Calzones

The headliners.

Our New York style hand-tossed crust, house-made sauce, and a blend of fresh mozzarella. Five sizes: 12", 14", 16", 20", and a 24" monster.

Big Jim's Special

Pepperoni, ham, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and green bell peppers.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Supreme Pizza

Pepperoni, ham, hamburger, Italian sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and green bell peppers.

12"
$18.99
14"
$20.99
16"
$25.99
20"
$32.99
24"
$39.99
Margherita Pizza

Fresh whole-milk mozzarella slices, basil, garlic, Italian seasonings, and extra-virgin olive oil.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
The Ulti-Meat Pizza

Pepperoni, ham, hamburger, Italian sausage, and bacon.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Veggie-Nator

Mushrooms, onions, green bell peppers, black olives, and green olives.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Jalapeño Popper Pizza

Cream cheese base, bacon, jalapeños, mozzarella, and cheddar.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Chicken Alfredo Pizza

House-made Alfredo sauce, chopped chicken breast, and bacon.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

House-made ranch base, mozzarella and cheddar, chicken, and bacon.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ sauce, mozzarella and cheddar, chicken, onions, and a BBQ drizzle.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Taco Pizza

Refried beans and house-made taco meat, lettuce, onions, olives, tomatoes, cheddar, and taco sauce on the side.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Lasagna Pizza

A classic Italian favorite meets your pizza on a thick crust.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Mac N' Cheese Pizza

Elbow macaroni in our house-made cheese sauce, topped with mozzarella and cheddar.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Chicken Fajita Pizza

Thin crust, refried beans, chicken, mozzarella, cheddar, onions, peppers, and hot sauce drizzle.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Chicken Enchilada Pizza

Sour cream base, mozzarella, cheddar, chicken, Hatch green chiles, and enchilada drizzle.

12"
$16.99
14"
$18.99
16"
$22.99
20"
$29.99
24"
$37.99
Sicarios

Two crispy crusts stacked like a double cross, loaded with mozzarella cheese, slow-braised birria beef, onions, cilantro, and a birria consommé and creamy mayo.

14"
$20.99
PLT Sandwich

Sauceless cheese pizza with crispy prosciutto, lettuce and tomato.

14"
$14.99
Cold Cheese Pizza

A Oneonta, NY staple — an extra layer of cold cheese on top.

12"
$15.49
14"
$16.99
16"
$18.49
20"
$22.49
24"
$28.99
Cheese Pizza

Start here and build your own.

12"
$11.99
14"
$12.99
16"
$13.99
20"
$17.99
24"
$23.99
Additional Toppings or Drizzle

Add any of our signature sauces.

12"
$2.00
14"
$2.25
16"
$2.50
20"
$3.25
24"
$4.00
Real Chicago Deep Dish

Jim brought the real thing from Chicago. Pick-up or dine-in only; please allow about an hour.

10" Cheese (feeds 2)
$16.99
14" Cheese (feeds 4)
$26.99

Additional toppings: 10" $2.50 · 14" $3.25
Calzone
$11.49

Fresh dough, mozzarella blend, just enough sauce, and your 2 favorite toppings — folded, baked, buttered, and topped with Parmesan.

Addt'l topping $0.75 · Make it a turnover (deep fried) $1.25
Guido Burrito
$11.49

Your choice of two toppings with house-made sauce and mozzarella, rolled in a tortilla and deep fried.

Addt'l topping $0.75

Starters & Shareables

Get the table started.

Pesto Mozzarella Rolls
$11.49

Fresh dough stuffed with mozzarella and kale pesto, rolled in cornmeal, baked golden with a garlic-butter finish.
Breadsticks
$5.49

House-made, baked with garlic and Parmesan. Comes with marinara.
Cheese Bread
$11.49

Fresh baked crust and melty cheese. Comes with marinara.
Bone-in Wings
$12.49

Breaded and deep-fried, hot sauce on the side, or tossed in a signature sauce.
Boneless Wings
$12.49

Breaded chicken breast pieces tossed in your choice of signature sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks
$11.49

Battered mozzarella fried crispy outside, stringy inside.
Cheese Curds
$11.49

Lightly beer-battered white cheddar curds. Try them with caramel.
Mac 'n Cheese Bites
$12.49

Smoked Gouda macaroni, lightly battered and golden fried.
Corn Nuggets
$11.49

Sweet creamed corn battered and golden fried.
Mini Tacos
$11.49

Mini corn tortillas filled with steak and cheese, fried. Taco sauce on the side.
Popcorn Chicken
$11.49

Popcorn-size bites of chicken.
Pickle Fries
$11.49

Corn battered and fried to a golden brown.
Fried Mushrooms
$11.49

Whole mushrooms battered and fried until crispy.

Subs, Burgers & Gyros

Pizza can share the stage.

Italian Beef
$15.99

Slow-roasted, thinly sliced, bathed in au jus, piled on a hoagie roll with melted mozzarella. Comes with fries or onion rings.
Meatball Sub
$12.49

Savory Italian meatballs in house-made marinara, topped with melted mozzarella.
Chicken Parmesan
$11.49

Crispy chicken, house-made marinara, melted mozzarella and Parmesan on a made-to-order bun.
Chicken Cordon Bleu
$11.49

Beer-battered chicken, brown sugar ham, and melted Swiss-American in a mayo-toasted bun.
Chicken Sub
$11.49

Grilled chicken breast, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes. Also available crispy.
Bacon Sub
$11.49

Our take on the BLT — chopped bacon, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Italian Sub
$11.49

Brown sugar ham and Genoa salami, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Ham and Cheese
$11.49

Brown sugar ham, melted Swiss-American, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Steak and Cheese Sub
$11.49

Ribeye chopped with mushrooms, grilled onions, and melted Swiss-American.
Pizza Sub
$11.49

Your choice of 3 toppings and house-made marinara, topped with melted mozzarella.
Three Cheese BBQ Chicken Sub
$11.49

Fried chicken in sweet BBQ, with Swiss-American, cheddar, and mozzarella.
Hamburger Deluxe
$13.49

Angus patty on a buttery toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and fries.

Extra patty $2.25 · Cheese/Bacon/Hatch chiles $1.50
Pizza Burger
$14.49

Angus patty smothered in marinara, 2 pizza toppings, mozzarella, on a garlic-butter bun. Fries included.

Additional toppings $1.00
Lamb Gyro
$11.49

Sliced lamb and grilled onions on a toasted pita, lettuce, tomatoes, and tzatziki.
Chicken Gyro
$11.49

Grilled chicken and grilled onions on a toasted pita, lettuce, tomatoes, and tzatziki.

Chicken & Seafood

Beyond the pizza box.

Wing Ding Dinner
$14.49

Our famous breaded wings, bone-in or boneless, with hot sauce on the side or tossed. Comes with fries and breadsticks.
Chicken Strip Dinner
$14.49

Tender, crispy chicken strips with fries and breadsticks.
Seafood Dinner
$20.99

Beer-battered fish fillets and Panko breaded shrimp with fries and breadsticks.
Fish Dinner
$16.49

Beer-battered white fish fillets with fries and breadsticks.
Jumbo Shrimp Dinner
$17.49

Butterflied, Panko-battered jumbo shrimp, golden fried, with fries and breadsticks.
Kane's Broke Boy
$15.49

Fish fillet and Panko shrimp in Gamechanger sauce, wrapped in pita with lettuce and tomatoes. Fries or onion rings.

Pasta & Salads

A fork works, too.

Spaghetti With Meat Sauce
$11.49

Angel hair, house-made marinara with beef crumbles, and breadsticks.

Add meatballs or Italian sausage $1.50 · Tray w/ breadsticks $42.99
Lasagna With Meat Sauce
$12.49

Savory lasagna in house-made marinara, topped with mozzarella. Comes with breadsticks.

Add meatballs or Italian sausage $1.50 · Tray w/ breadsticks $42.99
Chicken Alfredo
$12.49

Linguine in house-made Alfredo, topped with grilled chicken and breadsticks.

Tray w/ breadsticks $46.99
Tossed Salad

Fresh lettuce, pepperoncinis, olives, Roma tomatoes, breadsticks, and your choice of dressing.

Small
$8.49
Large
$10.49

Tray w/ breadsticks $35.99
Chicken Salad

Grilled or crispy chicken and cheddar over the tossed salad.

Small
$9.49
Large
$12.99

Tray w/ breadsticks $41.99
Greek Salad

Feta crumbles and sliced beets over the tossed salad.

Small
$9.49
Large
$13.99

Tray w/ breadsticks $41.99
Antipasto Salad

Ham, Genoa salami, and mozzarella over the tossed salad.

Small
$10.49
Large
$13.99

Tray w/ breadsticks $41.99
Taco Salad
$14.49

Fried flour tortilla packed with lettuce, onions, olives, tomatoes, cheddar, and taco meat, with beans and salsa. Add guac/sour cream extra.

Desserts

Save a little room.

Cinnamon Bread
$8.99

Crust buttered, coated with brown sugar and cinnamon, baked golden, with caramel and vanilla icing for dipping.
Oreo Pizza
$9.99

Buttered crust baked golden, vanilla icing, crumbled Oreos, and a chocolate syrup drizzle.
Whole Cheesecake
$27.99

Creamy New York style cheesecake.

Add chocolate, caramel, or cherries $6.50
Cheesecake Slice
$6.99

A slice with your choice of chocolate, caramel, or cherry topping.
Cannolis
$6.99

Delicate shells stuffed with chocolate chip cream and a chocolate drizzle.
Funnel Cake Sticks
$11.99

Fair-food favorite in bite-size sticks, with powdered sugar and chocolate. Shareable.

Order Online

Does Big Jim's have more than pizza?

A lot more. Burgers, gyros, calzones, subs, wings, pasta, salads, and seafood.

Is there a kids menu?

Yes. Jump to the Kids Menu section above to explore that part of the menu.

Any gluten-free or food-sensitivity options?

Yes, a full section. See our Gluten-Free page.

Way more than pizza.

The headliners.

Big Jim's Special

Supreme Pizza

Margherita Pizza

The Ulti-Meat Pizza

Veggie-Nator

Jalapeño Popper Pizza

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Taco Pizza

Lasagna Pizza

Mac N' Cheese Pizza

Chicken Fajita Pizza

Chicken Enchilada Pizza

Sicarios

PLT Sandwich

Cold Cheese Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Additional Toppings or Drizzle

Real Chicago Deep Dish

Calzone

Guido Burrito

Get the table started.

Pesto Mozzarella Rolls

Breadsticks

Cheese Bread

Bone-in Wings

Boneless Wings

Mozzarella Sticks

Cheese Curds

Mac 'n Cheese Bites

Corn Nuggets

Mini Tacos

Popcorn Chicken

Pickle Fries

Fried Mushrooms

Pizza can share the stage.

Italian Beef

Meatball Sub

Chicken Parmesan

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Chicken Sub

Bacon Sub

Italian Sub

Ham and Cheese

Steak and Cheese Sub

Pizza Sub

Three Cheese BBQ Chicken Sub

Hamburger Deluxe

Pizza Burger

Lamb Gyro

Chicken Gyro

Beyond the pizza box.

Wing Ding Dinner

Chicken Strip Dinner

Seafood Dinner

Fish Dinner

Jumbo Shrimp Dinner

Kane's Broke Boy

A fork works, too.

Spaghetti With Meat Sauce

Lasagna With Meat Sauce

Chicken Alfredo

Tossed Salad

Chicken Salad

Greek Salad

Antipasto Salad

Taco Salad

Room for a little extra.

Fries

Onion Rings

Save a little room.

Cinnamon Bread

Oreo Pizza

Whole Cheesecake

Cheesecake Slice

Cannolis

Funnel Cake Sticks